This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.
Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $60 away from free ground shipping within the USA. No code needed.

FAST SHIPPING: Your order ships within two business days! Shipping to US and Canada only.

Enjoy FREE domestic ground shipping on orders $60+. Excludes wholesale orders and priority/express upgrades.

Cart 0

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $60 away from free shipping.
No more products available for purchase

Products
Is this a gift?
Pair with
Subtotal Free
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes are calculated at checkout

Your Cart is Empty

The Color Wheel© Collection
All Products
Enamel Pins
RETIRING
Notepads
Stickers
Suncatchers
Keychains
Accessories
Gift Cards
Blog
Wholesale
Stockists

Retiring Products Collection

These products are being discontinued and will not be restocked. While the designs have been loved, we often retire pieces that no longer resonate to make space for new work and fresh inspiration. If something here speaks to you, now’s the time to grab it. Enjoy 25% off with code GOODBYE25 at checkout. 

Filters

Availability
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Color
More options
Creativity Raskog Cart enamel pin featuring a multilevel cart with labeled drawers on a pale pink background.
 
Creativity Raskog Cart enamel pin featuring a multilevel cart with labeled drawers on a pale pink background.
Creativity Cart Enamel Pin - The Gray Muse

RETIRING Creativity Raskog Cart Enamel Pin

$14.00
Bright blue floral sticker with white hand lettered quote about being the curator of an extensive private art supply collection on a white backing
Bright blue floral sticker with white hand lettered quote about being the curator of an extensive private art supply collection on a white backing
Dark themed sticker with white bold text of the same quote, shown held by fingers against a neutral background
Bright blue floral sticker with white hand lettered quote about being the curator of an extensive private art supply collection on a white backing
Close up of the same bright floral blue sticker held by a hand, featuring the curatorial art supply collection quote

RETIRING Curator of Art Matte Sticker

From $4.00
Black American Shorthair cat enamel pin held between fingers against a blurred background
 
Black American Shorthair cat enamel pin held between fingers against a blurred background
Black American Shorthair cat enamel pin mounted on a black display card

RETIRING Black American Shorthair Cat Enamel Pin

$14.00
Matte sticker with a white border featuring the quote THE ANSWER IS CRAFTING I DON T CARE WHAT THE QUESTION IS held by a finger against a pink background
Matte sticker with a white border featuring the quote THE ANSWER IS CRAFTING I DON T CARE WHAT THE QUESTION IS held by a finger against a pink background
Matte sticker with a white border featuring the quote THE ANSWER IS CRAFTING I DON T CARE WHAT THE QUESTION IS held by a finger against a pink background
Close up of the matte sticker with rainbow colored CRAFTING letters on a dark label held by a finger against a pale background

RETIRING The Answer is Crafting Matte Sticker

$3.50
 
White line art flower enamel pin with purple outline affixed to a black leather jacket.
 
White line art flower enamel pin with purple outline affixed to a black leather jacket.
Small one line art flower enamel pin on a white shirt collar.

RETIRING One Line Art Flower Mini Enamel Pin

$8.00
Rainbow watercolor paint tube enamel pin mounted on a black display card held by fingers
 
Rainbow watercolor paint tube enamel pin mounted on a black display card held by fingers
Close up of a rainbow watercolor paint tube enamel pin on a white background

Rainbow Watercolor Paint Tube Enamel Pin (Limited Batch)

$13.00
Ranunculus enamel pin with vibrant pink layered petals and green stem held between fingers
 
Ranunculus enamel pin with vibrant pink layered petals and green stem held between fingers
Pink ranunculus enamel pin with a green stem on a soft pink background

RETIRING Ranunculus Floral Enamel Pin

$13.00
Close up of a round pastel spinner enamel pin held between fingers showing affirmations
Close up of a round pastel spinner enamel pin held between fingers showing affirmations
Close up of a round pastel spinner enamel pin held between fingers showing affirmations
Two pastel colored spinner enamel pins on a light blue background

RETIRING Inner Child Interactive Spinner Enamel Pin

$14.00
Gold plated enamel pin of a white folder with rainbow tabs and paint splatters on a display card
 
Gold plated enamel pin of a white folder with rainbow tabs and paint splatters on a display card
Close-up of a gold-plated enamel pin depicting a white folder with rainbow tabs and colorful splatters, text reads My brain has too many tabs open.
Sale

RETIRING Too Many Tabs Rainbow Folder Enamel Pin

$10.00 $13.00
Don't Believe Every Thought matte sticker with a clear border black speckled background and pastel lettering held by a finger.
Don't Believe Every Thought matte sticker with a clear border black speckled background and pastel lettering held by a finger.
Don't Believe Every Thought matte sticker with a clear border black speckled background and pastel lettering held by a finger.
Don't Believe Every Thought You Think sticker with starry black background and pastel gradient lettering held by fingers.

RETIRING Don't Believe Every Thought Matte Sticker

$3.50
 
Tortoiseshell cat enamel pin held between fingers showing a multicolor mosaic design
 
Tortoiseshell cat enamel pin held between fingers showing a multicolor mosaic design
Tortoiseshell cat enamel pin mounted on a black display card with the logo above

RETIRING Tortoiseshell Cat Enamel Pin

$14.00
Matte sticker with a clear border displaying Your worthiness is not tied to how much you get done with white text on black and a small gold M logo
 
Matte sticker with a clear border displaying Your worthiness is not tied to how much you get done with white text on black and a small gold M logo
Close up of Your worthiness sticker held by fingers showing white text on black with a small gold M logo

RETIRING Your Worthiness Matte Sticker

$4.00
Close-up of a pink chrysanthemum enamel pin held by fingers against a blurred green background.
 
Close-up of a pink chrysanthemum enamel pin held by fingers against a blurred green background.
Chrysanthemum enamel pin mounted on a black display card with The Gray Muse logo.

RETIRING Chrysanthemum v2 Floral Enamel Pin | November Birth Month Flower (Limited Batch)

$13.00
Lavender enamel pin held between fingers, detailed purple blossom and green leaves.
 
Lavender enamel pin held between fingers, detailed purple blossom and green leaves.
Lavender enamel pin attached to a black display card with The Gray Muse logo.

RETIRING Lavender v2 Floral Enamel Pin

$13.00
Tuxedo cat enamel pin held between fingers against a soft blurred background
 
Tuxedo cat enamel pin held between fingers against a soft blurred background
Tuxedo cat enamel pin mounted on a black display card with The Gray Muse logo

RETIRING Tuxedo Cat Enamel Pin

$14.00
Gladiolus enamel pin in pink and magenta hues held between fingers against a soft green background
 
Gladiolus enamel pin in pink and magenta hues held between fingers against a soft green background
Gladiolus enamel pin with pink flowers and green stem on a pink backdrop

RETIRING Gladiolus Floral Enamel Pin | August Birth Month Flower

$13.00
Two pale blue magnolia blossoms with green leaves enamel pin held between fingers.
 
Two pale blue magnolia blossoms with green leaves enamel pin held between fingers.
Magnolia blossom enamel pin with white petals and lime green leaves on a dark background.

RETIRING Magnolia Blossom Floral Enamel Pin (v2) | Louisiana State Flower | Mississippi State Flower

$13.00
Calico Cat v2 enamel pin with a gold edge held between fingers showing its calico pattern
 
Calico Cat v2 enamel pin with a gold edge held between fingers showing its calico pattern
Calico Cat enamel pin mounted on a black display card with The Gray Muse logo.

RETIRING Calico Cat v2 Enamel Pin

$14.00
I am not lost I am exploring sticker with white text and rainbow colored exploring on a dark background.
Matte sticker showing the phrase I'm not lost I'm exploring with the word exploring in rainbow colors, held by a fingertip
I am not lost I am exploring sticker with white text and rainbow colored exploring on a dark background.
Matte sticker showing the phrase I'm not lost I'm exploring with the word exploring in rainbow colors, held by a fingertip

RETIRING I'm Exploring Matte Sticker

$3.50
 
Hand holding a brown tabby cat enamel pin against a blurred background
 
Hand holding a brown tabby cat enamel pin against a blurred background
Brown tabby cat enamel pin mounted on a black display card with The Gray Muse logo

RETIRING Brown Tabby Cat Enamel Pin

$14.00
1.3 inch orange tabby cat enamel pin held between fingers against a blurred background
 
1.3 inch orange tabby cat enamel pin held between fingers against a blurred background
Orange tabby cat enamel pin mounted on a black display card with The Gray Muse logo

RETIRING Orange Cat v2 Enamel Pin

$14.00
Hand holding a black display card featuring a gold-plated black marble fountain pen enamel pin.
 
Hand holding a black display card featuring a gold-plated black marble fountain pen enamel pin.
Close up of the black marble fountain pen enamel pin with gold plating on a black card.

RETIRING Fountain Pen (Black Marble) Enamel Pin

$13.00
It's Not a Mistake If I'm Learning matte sticker with bold black text and a pink highlight on LEARNING against a light pink backdrop
It's Not a Mistake If I'm Learning matte sticker with bold black text and a pink highlight on LEARNING against a light pink backdrop
It's Not a Mistake If I'm Learning matte sticker with bold black text and a pink highlight on LEARNING against a light pink backdrop
Hand holding the It's Not a Mistake If I'm Learning sticker showing a pale pink label with black text and pink LEARNING accent on a dark background

RETIRING It's Not a Mistake Matte Sticker

$3.50
 
White rose enamel pin held between fingers outdoors against a green blurred background
 
White rose enamel pin held between fingers outdoors against a green blurred background
White rose enamel pin with gold edge and green stem on a dark background

RETIRING Rose (White) Enamel Pin | June Birth Month Flower | New York State Flower

$13.00